No wonder it didn’t win our taste test of the best vanilla ice cream. Naturally, the false advertising led to a class action lawsuit, and Breyers has agreed to settle to the tune of $8.85 million.

Clear some freezer space, now! When you think of your ice cream truck favorite, Good Humor bars likely come to mind ...

We compared Breyers Natural Vanilla Ice Cream with Breyers Extra Creamy Vanilla Frozen Dessert. The ice cream was very good, with vanilla-bean and dairy flavors. The frozen dessert? Just OK ...